So Long to John Dingell, One of the Greats
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- The U.S. lost an important one on Thursday. “Master legislator” John Dingell, who served in Congress longer than anyone and was a key player in countless pieces of important legislation, has died.
An oddity of American public life is that we just don’t like Congress very much. We’re about to celebrate the birth of the first president later this month, and whether the holiday is called “Washington’s Birthday,” “Presidents’ Day” or some other variation, we think it’s perfectly normal to commemorate the chief executives. But it’s hard to imagine a “Members of Congress Day.” Nor do the great legislators really receive much appreciation (unless, as with Senator John McCain, they were famous for something else). I doubt if 5 percent of the country had any clue who John Dingell was.
And that’s a shame. Members of Congress – and especially the House – have always had the closest connection to ordinary voters. They’re the ones who do a lot of the serious work of democracy.
Dingell was first elected in 1955, beginning a record-breaking tenure that lasted through the start of 2015. As the long-time chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, he had a hand in bill after bill after bill, whether on the environment, industry, health care or innumerable other important issues. His fights over jurisdiction were famous and, most often, successful; he was widely admired as a master of getting things done. Many of us who have taught courses on Congress have asked our students to reflect on a quote of his: “I'll let you write the substance … you let me write the procedure, and I'll screw you every time.”
I see appreciations of him here, here, and here, and a constituent story here. The best tribute to Dingell, though, would be if the current House successfully completes the round of internal reforms it’s considering, thereby restoring resources and influence to the committees and subcommittees that have eroded badly since Dingell’s peak years.
John Dingell was a hero of the republic. One of the true greats.
1. Great analysis of the State of the Union speech by Maraam Dwidar, Connor Dye, E.J. Fagan, Katie Madel and Laura Quaglia at the Monkey Cage. Key finding: Donald Trump’s speech “was remarkable for its lack of policy content.” That’s consistent with what I’ve been saying, which is that he’s wasting these opportunities. We’ve seen that after the speech as well, with virtually no follow-up from Trump or the White House to advance what little policy there was.
2. Marian Currinder at Mischiefs of Faction on Lyndon Johnson and building influence in Congress.
3. John Sides at the Monkey Cage on public opinion about blackface.
4. David Byler on nomination challenges to Trump. Yup: If Trump is unpopular enough, almost any warm body could win a third or so of the primary votes in many states. But it’s extremely hard to imagine anyone beating Trump without solid, orthodox Republican positions on key policy questions.
5. David Roberts gives a basically positive review of the Green New Deal resolution rolled out Thursday.
6. And Jonathan Chait is not as impressed by the Green New Deal.
Get Early Returns every morning in your inbox. Click here to subscribe. Also subscribe to Bloomberg All Access and get much, much more. You’ll receive our unmatched global news coverage and two in-depth daily newsletters, the Bloomberg Open and the Bloomberg Close.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy. He taught political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University and wrote A Plain Blog About Politics.
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.