Job Growth Won't Change the Fed's Mind on Rates

(Bloomberg View) -- Although the July employment report was strong, it does nothing to fundamentally change the outlook for the Federal Reserve. And employment reports in future months are likely to similarly take a back seat to the most critical trigger factor for monetary policy: inflation -- or lack thereof.

The July employment report highlighted the growth trend in the U.S. labor market that we have seen since the Great Recession, with the number of jobs created exceeding forecasts while sending the unemployment rate lower.

Despite the health of the U.S. job market, a September Fed rate hike is widely considered unlikely, and even a December increase doesn't appear to be a guarantee. In fact, the CME Fed Funds Futures showed the chance of no rate change in December at less than 50 percent. This is because, against the backdrop of an improving labor market, wage inflation remained tepid at only 2.5 percent. Granted, the level of wage inflation is higher than the core inflation measure -- which excludes volatile food and energy prices -- of only 1.5 percent in the second quarter, but it is very low for a labor market that looks hot.

Job Growth Won't Change the Fed's Mind on Rates

But the labor market isn't as hot as it appears, and inflation is being held back by low levels of labor force participation. Annual labor force participation bottomed out in 2015 at 62.7 percent -- the lowest annual rate since 1977. In 2016, despite the job gains and a fall in unemployment, the annual average labor participation rate rose to only 62.8 percent, which was only a modest bump -- and it was still the lowest level since 1977. In the latest employment report, the participation rate was 62.9 percent. In other words, even with the job growth there's little sign of a resurgence in labor force participation. It’s not that the labor market isn’t tight; it’s just that there are more people on the sidelines now then there have been in 40 years.

Job Growth Won't Change the Fed's Mind on Rates

Since the Great Recession, we have seen the labor force participation rate retreat to levels not seen since the 1970s, when women began entering the workforce in large numbers. Unless wages rise substantially, the participation rate is likely to remain low. And yet, without a higher participation rate accompanying a low unemployment rate, wages are unlikely to rise significantly.

This indicates that still more jobs need to be created for the U.S. labor market to become tight. For the Fed, this slack in the sidelines of the U.S. labor market may keep inflationary pressures at bay, presenting challenges for the Fed’s plan to tighten monetary policy. This suggests the Federal Open Market Committee members’ June 2017 mean forecast of a midpoint fed funds rate at the end of 2018 of 2.23 percent is unlikely.

This dynamic means that although today’s employment report is likely to prove supportive for the dollar, the trend of weakening since the beginning of the year could continue. Plus, the dollar is brushing up against a technical level that has been a critical inflection point for the greenback at various times in the last 20 years. In other words, even though the dollar has fallen since the beginning of the year, if we cross that line to the downside, there could be significantly more downside ahead.

Job Growth Won't Change the Fed's Mind on Rates

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

Jason Schenker is president and founder at Prestige Economics LLC.

To contact the author of this story: Jason Schenker at

For more columns from Bloomberg View, visit