Why Chinese and Indian Troops Clashed in the Himalayas
(Bloomberg) -- China and India, two nuclear-armed powers with a combined population of 2.7 billion, gathered thousands of troops at a disputed border in the Himalayas last year -- the latest confrontation in a long history that includes a war in 1962 and a skirmish near Bhutan in 2017. Weeks of skirmishes led to the first deadly clashes along the un-demarcated border in four decades. Although some troops began pulling back early this year, other disputed border areas remain. The disengagement belies a growing Chinese assertiveness that may prod India to align more closely with the U.S. in the region.
1. What’s this dispute about?
On May 5, China surprised India by deploying troops in three main locations, two of them in Ladakh, a remote part of northernmost India abutting Tibet (an autonomous region of China) and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. The 3,488 kilometer (2,167 miles) border is ill-defined and the reason for the maneuver was unclear, but earlier actions by India regarding the territories of Ladakh, whose people are culturally close to Tibet, and Kashmir had drawn angry responses from its neighbors. China has accused India of seeking “to undermine its territorial sovereignty.”
2. How bad did it get?
The confrontation was centered on the Galwan River area and Pangong Tso, a glacial lake at 14,000 feet (4,300 meters) in the Tibetan plateau. After weeks of skirmishes, 20 Indian soldiers died in mid-June in a clash with Chinese troops. The PLA Daily reported -- eight months later -- that four Chinese soldiers were also killed in that clash. Tensions flared again on Aug. 31 after India moved troops to the hilltops on its side of the border at Pangong Tso lake to stop a push by Chinese forces. In September, the two sides renewed pledges to de-escalate tensions after their defense and foreign ministers met for the first time since the standoff began. That was followed by an agreement to stop sending troops to the front line and, in February, confirmation of a pullback from Pangong lake. India’s defense minister Rajnath Singh said another round of talks between military commanders would be held to discuss withdrawing soldiers from other disputed areas along the frontier.
3. How old is the India-China border conflict?
It dates back to the 1950s. Skirmishes were reported after India granted the Dalai Lama asylum following an uprising against Chinese rule in Tibet in 1959. War broke out three years later after China objected to India establishing outposts along the effective boundary, established by the British in 1914, between the Tibetan region and Northeast India. The current “Line of Actual Control” that forms the ambiguous border partially adheres to the British-drawn boundaries. Clashes were also reported in 1967 and again in 1987 in what’s sometimes referred to as the loudspeaker war -- no bullets were fired and soldiers simply kept shouting at each other via loudspeakers. Relations improved as the two governments signed five treaties between 1993 and 2013 and -- with economic growth racing ahead in both countries -- China became India’s largest trading partner. The border remained mostly calm through 2017, when troops faced off for several months at Doklam, a plateau near the Indian border that is claimed by both China and Bhutan. The clashes are mostly seasonal, given the harsh winter conditions.
4. What’s different now?
The context. The coronavirus outbreak has infected more than 10.8 million people and severely damaged the economy over the past year. India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi has also been shifting his country closer to the U.S. as relations with China have worsened. Since 2017, India has signed crucial communications and arms agreements with the U.S. and blocked dozens of Chinese apps on national security grounds. India has also prevented Chinese companies from taking over local businesses and stepped up road construction in border areas. China has been building border infrastructure for decades, including -- to India’s chagrin -- through disputed areas that link China to Pakistan. Meanwhile, China is getting more assertive. It pressed ahead in the face of international condemnation with a new security law in Hong Kong, while also getting involved in more military run-ins in the South China Sea and warning Taiwan against any moves toward independence.
5. Will tensions escalate?
Most observers had been speculating that war was unlikely since neither side wanted to escalate matters. One outcome may be closer alignment between India and the U.S. The U.S. has been broadening trade and strategic ties with countries in the Indo-Pacific region. The long-moribund Quad -- a security framework with the U.S., Japan and Australia -- has been revived and in November held naval exercises in the Indian Ocean. Still, there’s always a chance border scuffles will resume elsewhere. India last year opened a bridge to enable faster movement of troops and artillery in the region of the 2017 border clashes.
The Reference Shelf
- China’s border invasion will push India toward U.S., according to Bloomberg Opinion columnist Hal Brands.
- Former Indian Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon writes about China’s ambitions in an article for the Asia Society Policy Institute.
- QuickTakes on the South China Sea tensions, China’s spat with Australia, Taiwan and the new laws China is pushing for Hong Kong.
- Bloomberg News examines how China blew a chance at global leadership responding to Covid-19.
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.