White-Collar Crime Probes Likely to Intensify Under Biden’s DOJ
(Bloomberg) -- President-elect Joe Biden’s Justice Department is likely to ramp up white-collar crime enforcement, putting Wall Street firms and corporate executives under greater scrutiny.
Fines and prosecutions of white-collar crimes fell during the Donald Trump administration, but lawyers are anticipating a ramp up that would return the government to its past practice of scrutinizing corporate wrongdoing. Robert Anello, a defense lawyer in New York, said his white-collar practice like many others in Manhattan, ground to a halt during the Trump administration.
High on the agenda for federal prosecutors are likely to be tax cheats and foreign-bribery cases, Anello and other lawyers said. In addition, there will be lots of potential charges to come out of the rush of government funding disbursed to offset effects of the pandemic, including the Paycheck Protection Program, which grew to $525 billion and used thousands of banks, lawyers said.
Duke University law professor Brandon Garrett, who has studied corporate crime prosecution under the Trump and Barack Obama presidencies, says a shift under Biden, a public defender before going into politics, may not be immediately obvious as securities prosecutions can take many months or years to build. He expects more such cases, which can include insider-trading investigations and accounting scams.
“There’s often kind of a life cycle to fraud,” Garrett said. “If we have lax enforcement for a number of years, there will be a lot of serious misconduct and fraud that will have been brushed under the rug and so I would expect a serious backlog of cases of all types.”
A Justice Department spokesman declined to comment on the administration’s record. Biden’s transition team didn’t respond to a request for comment.
Trump calls himself the “law and order” president, but when it comes to white collar crime, he has overseen a significant decline in enforcement. The U.S. prosecution of securities fraud, antitrust violations and other such crimes has hit a record low as the pandemic slows the courts, but even before the coronavirus, the figures were falling, according to Syracuse University’s Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, or TRAC.
The Justice Department has said it’s been tough on white-collar criminals, but TRAC’s data show a drop of about 30% in average annual prosecutions under Trump as compared with Obama.
Corporate fines fell 76% in Trump’s first 20 months compared with the last 20 months of the Obama administration, Garrett said. During Trump’s first 20 months in office, corporate penalties totaled just $3.4 billion, paid by 17 financial institutions and 13 public companies. That compares with $14.15 billion in total corporate penalties, affecting 71 financial institutions and 34 public companies, during the last 20 months of Obama.
“Anything would be a step up from Trump’s complete neglect of white-collar crime,” said Cheryl Bader, a professor at Fordham Law School in New York. “He wants to see himself as the business-friendly president.”
The waning days of the Trump administration did see several notable corporate cases end in guilty pleas. Goldman Sachs Group Inc. reached a deal in which its Malaysia unit pleaded guilty and agreed to pay $2.9 billion in penalties for conspiring to pay overseas bribes. That case began under the Obama administration.
Purdue Pharma LP also agreed to plead guilty to felony charges and pay a hefty fine to settle probes of the marketing of OxyContin, the highly addictive painkiller blamed for helping spark the U.S. opioid epidemic. No individuals were charged.
“When Trump talks about law and order, he’s not talking about law and order as relates to white-collar crime,” said Joel Cohen, a former federal prosecutor in New York now in private practice. “He’s talking about law and order, frankly in terms of minority people.”
To the surprise of some, bribery cases have been “extremely robust” over the past four years, said Mike Koehler, a law professor at Southern Illinois University School of Law, who runs a website dedicated to the law. But during his tenure, Trump has also pushed his Justice Department to go after gangs, immigrants, left-wing activists and even political opponents, rather than corporate wrongdoers.
A. Brian Albritton, who served as the top federal prosecutor in central Florida under Presidents George W. Bush and Obama, expects more fraud cases involving health care and stock swindles, like those he targeted as U.S. attorney from 2008 to 2010.
“Violent crime has been a priority for the Trump administration,” said Albritton, now a partner at Phelps Dunbar LLP in Tampa. “I would anticipate fewer resources devoted to immigration crimes.”
Biden will set the tone for his Justice Department when he names his attorney general, and early speculation includes New York Governor Andrew Cuomo and former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates, both of whom have experience prosecuting white-collar cases.
Whoever Biden picks will first have to restore morale in a Justice Department that became partisan under Trump and Attorney General William Barr, said Jennifer Rodgers, a former federal prosecutor who now lectures at Columbia Law School.
“Anyone going into DOJ and a new administration is going to have a lot of work to do and a lot of priorities,” Rogers said. “Someone coming in will need to immediately say, ‘We’re not doing this anymore.’”
©2020 Bloomberg L.P.