U.S. Denounces China’s Claims to South China Sea as Unlawful
Fishermen prepare to offload fish from a boat at Tan Quang harbor in Quang Nam province, Vietnam. (Photographer: Maika Elan/Bloomberg)

U.S. Denounces China’s Claims to South China Sea as Unlawful


The Trump administration rejected China’s expansive maritime claims in the South China Sea, reversing a previous policy of not taking sides in such disputes and escalating tensions with Beijing on yet another front.

The move aligns the U.S. with a 2016 ruling by a United Nations tribunal that found China’s claims to waters also contested by the Philippines were unlawful. It’s meant to push back against what the U.S. sees as an intensifying Chinese campaign to dominate the resource-rich South China Sea and smaller nations in the region.

“We are making clear: Beijing’s claims to offshore resources across most of the South China Sea are completely unlawful, as is its campaign of bullying to control them,” Secretary of State Michael Pompeo said in a statement Monday.

U.S. Denounces China’s Claims to South China Sea as Unlawful

In the past, the U.S. largely limited itself to calling for ensuring “freedom of navigation” in the contested waterway, which is critical for global trade routes, while stopping short of taking a position on specific claims. China has proceeded nonetheless, engaging in a years-long campaign to build bases and other outposts on shoals, reefs and rock outcroppings as a way of deepening its claims.

China on Tuesday said the U.S. statement “neglected the history and facts” around issues concerning the South China Sea.

“The U.S., out of its selfish agenda, is doing all it can to stir up trouble in the South China Sea and drive a wedge between regional countries and China, aiming to disrupt China’s and ASEAN countries’ efforts to maintain peace and stability,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian said at a daily briefing in Beijing, referring to the Association of Southeast Asian Nations.

“China does not seek to build a maritime empire in the South China Sea. We have been treating our neighboring countries as equals and we have been keeping maximum restraint in safeguarding sovereignty and interests in the South China Sea,” he said.

Zhao said China and the ASEAN bloc were accelerating discussions on a Code of Conduct to jointly safeguard peace, stability and freedom of navigation in the disputed waters. “We have made progress in our consultations,” he said.

Regional countries weighed in, with the Philippines urging China to “heed the call of the community of nations to follow international law and honor existing international agreements.”

“We continue to push for the finalization of a substantive Code of Conduct in the South China Sea to settle disputes and prevent the escalation of tensions in the region,” Philippine Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana said in a statement.

Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga told reporters in Tokyo on Tuesday that his country was “very concerned” about China’s recent activities in the waters.

“We understand that the U.S. announcement represents the unwavering commitment of the U.S. to regional peace and stability. We support such a commitment by the U.S.,” Suga said. Japan is a key U.S. military ally.

Growing Differences

While the immediate impact of the U.S. decision isn’t clear, it adds to conflicts over issues from trade to cybersecurity and President Donald Trump’s efforts to blame China for the coronavirus pandemic that began there. Last week, the U.S. slapped sanctions on a top Chinese official over human rights abuses in the Xinjiang region, and China responded by imposing sanctions on Senators Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz.

Among the demands that the UN tribunal -- and now the U.S. -- are rejecting are China’s claims in waters surrounding Vanguard Bank off Vietnam and Luconia Shoals off Malaysia. The U.S. also says China can’t claim any maritime rights around Scarborough Shoal off the Philippines or features including Mischief Reef that are submerged at high tide.

U.S. Denounces China’s Claims to South China Sea as Unlawful

Most recently, the U.S. had raised concern over China’s decision to conduct military exercises in the contested waters around the Paracel Islands in the South China Sea. The Defense Department last week called the actions “unlawful.”

The top State Department official for East Asia, Assistant Secretary David Stilwell, said in an interview the U.S. hoped its announcement Monday would give cover to other nations in the region to contest their own claims against China. He said the change doesn’t mean the U.S. is taking sides in specific disputes over land -- such as islands that China and other nations also claim.

“These laws exist to prevent the Chinese approach of big countries pretty much dominating small countries,” Stilwell said. “The threat of using that excessive weight, both economic and otherwise, has cowed them into not ending their claims but acquiescing for a time. What we are doing I believe gives them the space to assert their own claims.”

Stretching from China in the north to Indonesia in the south, the South China Sea encompasses 1.4 million square miles (3.6 million square kilometers). Over the last several years, China has engaged in an extensive campaign to build up many of the land features in the region as a way of extending its claims to the entire region.

U.S. Denounces China’s Claims to South China Sea as Unlawful

“The move provides the legal basis for the U.S. to take more forceful steps to back other claimants’ rights to fish and develop energy” within their exclusive economic zones, said Bonnie Glaser, senior adviser for Asia and the director of the China Power Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.

Trump administration officials have long accused past administrations, and especially that of former President Barack Obama, of doing too little to challenge China’s territorial moves. This month, the U.S. announced it was sending the USS Ronald Reagan and USS Nimitz aircraft carriers to the South China Sea for military exercises as China ramps up its own drills in the area.

The question now is what the U.S. will do if China continues to violate the UN tribunal’s ruling. The U.S. has a decades-old defense treaty with the Philippines but no such agreement with other nations involved in territorial and maritime disputes with China.

Critics of the Trump administration approach have said they worry that neither side appears willing to back down, raising the possibility that tensions will only escalate further and could even lead to a clash at sea.

Stilwell said the U.S. wants to talk to China but said such discussions need to be productive.

“The door has remained open as long as I’ve been in this seat to an honest, results-based conversation,” Stilwell said. “The Chinese need to understand that we are serious and we are going to discuss these things in a serious manner.”

©2020 Bloomberg L.P.

BQ Install

Bloomberg Quint

Add BloombergQuint App to Home screen.