ADVERTISEMENT

Trump Awards Medal to Controversial Tax-Cut Champion Laffer

Trump Awards Medal to Controversial Tax-Cut Champion Laffer

(Bloomberg) -- History hasn’t exactly put the “Laffer Curve” on a pedestal, but Donald Trump nonetheless bestowed the nation’s highest civilian honor on its namesake on Wednesday, the inspiration behind decades of Republican tax proposals.

The president awarded the Medal of Freedom to economist Arthur Laffer, an economic adviser to Trump’s 2016 campaign and co-author of “Trumponomics: Inside the America First Plan to Revive Our Economy.”

“Few people in history have revolutionized” economic thought and policy like Laffer, Trump said. He hosted the event shortly after returning from a trip to Florida where he officially launched his 2020 re-election campaign.

Laffer, 78, who was an aide to President Ronald Reagan, is known for his eponymous “curve,” which supposes that taxation rates beyond a certain level can prove counterproductive by discouraging work. The argument is frequently cited by Republican lawmakers, including Trump, in support of tax cuts.

“Generally, the idea that lowering tax rates will increase revenue has been disproven time and time again,” said Joel Slemrod, professor of business economics and public policy and director of the Office of Tax Policy Research at the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business.

“It certainly makes tax cuts look more attractive if you claim you won’t lose revenue, so it’s very attractive politically to claim it -- but it’s almost never true,” he said.

Budget Deficits

Republican tax cuts, including Trump’s overhaul in 2017, are usually followed by increases in budget deficits. The U.S. budget deficit widened to $739 billion in the first eight months of the 2019 fiscal year, the Treasury Department said this month -- a $206 billion increase from a year earlier.

But Laffer’s curve accurately points to the need to consider how businesses and ordinary people will react to tax rates, Slemrod said, because it’s usually true that “the more you tax something, the less you get of it.”

Trump administration officials have repeatedly claimed the president’s tax cut will eventually yield more revenue for the federal government. And Laffer’s defenders say his model has never truly been tested.

Economist Douglas Holtz-Eakin, the president of American Action Forum, a centrist-right advocacy group, said that just because Laffer’s famous curve has never transpired in the real world doesn’t mean it can’t ever happen.

“We’ve never had a real-world experiment like the one he discussed” in his model, Holtz-Eakin said. “Academics like to sneer because he’s not an academic researcher. And he’s not a politician. But if you wanted to find a person you could associate with major tax cuts, you’d find Art Laffer.”

Kansas ‘Experiment’

In 2012, the state of Kansas hired Laffer to advise then-Governor Sam Brownback as he prepared his own tax cut proposal. The economist, who was paid $75,000 according to the Kansas City Star, argued that deep tax cuts would spur growth that would create more jobs and bring in more payroll tax revenue during a series of appearances in Topeka.

“More employment, more output, more production,” he said in an interview with NPR at the time.

Laffer was assisted in his Kansas campaign by the co-author of his Trump book, Stephen Moore, whom the president tried to place on the Federal Reserve’s board of governors this year. Moore attended the Medal of Freedom ceremony on Wednesday.

In fact, Brownback’s cuts -- which he described as a “real-life experiment” for the school of supply-side economics espoused by Laffer -- led to job growth far below expectations and a massive budget shortfall. Private sector job growth in Kansas following the cut was lower than all of the state’s neighbors except Oklahoma, and less than half the national growth rate, according to the liberal Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Steep declines in state revenues led to deficits of hundreds of millions of dollars annually.

In June 2017, the Kansas legislature overrode Brownback’s veto of a bill that rolled back some $1.2 billion in tax cuts over two years, in a bipartisan repudiation of Laffer’s plan.

Laffer has said the problem in Kansas was that Brownback’s tax cut didn’t go far enough. “When you put an atomic bomb on a place, it will materially change the place – but a cherry bomb probably won’t change the buildings or anything else,” he told The Guardian in 2017.

The medal event came hours after Fed Chairman Jerome Powell responded to a Bloomberg News report that Trump asked White House lawyers to explore removing him in February. “I think the law is clear that I have a four-year term, and I fully intend to serve it,” Powell said at a news conference in Washington following a two-day policy meeting at the central bank.

Laffer has echoed Trump in arguing that the Fed should lower interest rates. But unlike the president, he’s said he is a “huge fan” of Powell. He’s also said that tariffs on imports, which Trump has used as a tool to pressure U.S. trade partners, amount to tax hikes on U.S. consumers -- a position Trump has repeatedly rejected.

--With assistance from Lynnley Browning.

To contact the reporters on this story: Margaret Talev in Washington at mtalev@bloomberg.net;Justin Sink in Washington at jsink1@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Alex Wayne at awayne3@bloomberg.net, Joshua Gallu

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.