Berlin Voters Back Wresting Apartments Away From Landlords
(Bloomberg) -- Voters in Berlin backed a non-binding referendum to forcibly buy housing owned by large property companies in the German capital amid public anger over rising rents.
The proposal, which got 56% support, could mean transferring about 226,000 apartments into public hands if enacted. That includes those of Deutsche Wohnen SE, which owns more than 100,000 units in the city, and Vonovia SE.
The vote reflects frustration about housing inequality that’s being seen around the world, and which is proving an increasing headache for governments.
In Berlin, where more than 84% of the population are tenants, it underscores the divide between people feeling squeezed out of an increasingly expensive rental market and those who want to maintain the city as a hub that attracts companies, capital and housing investment. It’s unclear whether the next local government will follow through with the plan, which could lead to lengthy legal battles and billions of euros in costs.
The proposal applies to property companies that own more than 3,000 rental units. Deutsche Wohnen said it doesn’t expect that expropriation of flats will happen, and that such a move would be unconstitutional.
Vonovia climbed 4.2% in Frankfurt as of 1:38 p.m. local time. Deutsche Wohnen was little changed.
The vote coincided with elections for Berlin’s city government, in which the Social Democrats pulled ahead of the Greens -- meaning they’ll get a chance to appoint the next mayor. The party’s candidate, Franziska Giffey, said while the outcome of the referendum must be respected, expropriation won’t create new apartments or solve the wider housing issue.
But Rouzbeh Taheri, a spokesperson for the referendum initiators, said his group will keep up pressure on politicians to actually carry out the measure.
“This result has given the issues of rents and housing a new importance in Berlin,” Taheri told reporters on Monday. “No political party will be able to ignore that.”
Still, it’s far from certain the government will act. A previous referendum that sought to keep the popular but comparatively tiny Tegel airport open, also failed to change the ultimate outcome. While Berliners voted in favor, the airfield has since closed.
Since the fall of the Berlin Wall more than 30 years ago, the once-divided capital has morphed into a thriving metropolis attracting companies that offer high-paying jobs. Rents have shot up over the years, and Berlin has estimated that it needs 20,000 new homes annually to accommodate the growing population.
Supporters of the proposal argue that the government is better suited to keep a lid on rising housing costs.
But the cost of nationalizing vast amounts of housing is also an issue. Opponents say the price tag would be between 29 billion euros ($34 billion) and 39 billion euros, funds that should be made available for other projects.
Vonovia said Monday that while the referendum is a sign that the housing situation needs to change, expropriation would only make things worse.
“Not a single new apartment would be created and investments in modernization would come to a halt,” the landlord said. Vonovia and Deutsche Wohnen earlier this month agreed to sell 14,750 apartments to Berlin as part of their effort to merge.
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.