Collins Says Kavanaugh Is Unlikely to Favor Overturning Roe
(Bloomberg) -- Senator Susan Collins, a key swing vote in the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh, said Tuesday she doesn’t think President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee would overturn the Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion because he said he respects precedent.
Collins, a Maine Republican who supports abortion rights, said her discussions with Kavanaugh persuaded her that he believes “the concept of precedent is rooted in Article III of the Constitution, and he clearly reveres our Constitution."
Collins told reporters in Washington that the nominee “also believes that it is not sufficient -- since I asked him this directly -- for five sitting judges to believe that an earlier decision was incorrectly decided. He said it would have to be grievously wrong and deeply inconsistent."
Collins said she hasn’t decided whether she’ll vote in favor of confirming Kavanaugh to the court. She’s waiting to make a decision until after hearing testimony at a Thursday Senate Judiciary Committee hearing from a woman who accuses Kavanaugh of sexual assault during high school.
The nomination would fail if Collins and another Republican join all of the Democrats in opposing Kavanaugh. Collins faces heavy pressure from conservatives to support Kavanaugh, and from liberals to reject him in part because he could cast a deciding vote to overturn or gut Roe.
Kavanaugh declined during his confirmation hearings to say if Roe was correctly decided or if he’d vote to uphold it as a justice.
Collins said another reason she thinks the nominee wouldn’t do so is that he pointed to the duration of the precedent.
"Roe was decided in 1973, and it was reaffirmed 26 years ago in Planned Parenthood v. Casey,” Collins said. “So there’s been a reliance on Roe for 45 years, and he says that that matters.”
©2018 Bloomberg L.P.