For Naftali Bennett, It Was Never About the Money
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- Most Israeli premiers arrive from the public sector or the military. Naftali Bennett is the first to enter politics from the world of tech. Fresh out of the army in 1999, he co-founded anti-fraud company Cyota, which was bought out by security company RSA in 2005 for $145 million. Eight years later, as an investor and CEO of Soluto, he led another exit; this one valued at $100 million.
Those may sound like small numbers today, but that was before Israel was dubbed the “start-up nation.” Had he stayed in business, some in Israel’s tech sector today reckon he’d be one the richest Israelis.
He was still celebrating his new victory when news came that Payoneer, an Israeli company in which Bennett was an early investor, is merging with an American SPAC and will be listed on Nasdaq with a $3.2 billion valuation. Forbes Israel estimates that Bennett’s share will reap $5 million. Local insiders say it could be much higher.
He’s almost certainly the richest prime minister in the country’s history. But money, for Bennett, was a means to an end; his dream was to be prime minister. Having reached that goal, the question is: What will he do as the country’s leader?
Clearly, he will not enjoy the almost unfettered power of his former boss and bitter rival, Benjamin Netanyahu. Bennett will be leading a government in which his Yemina Party is only the fifth-largest coalition faction.
His coalition, composed of eight parties across the ideological spectrum, will not be capable of big-ticket foreign policy initiatives. Bennett’s foreign policy aims will focus, as all Israeli prime ministers do, on Israel’s relationship with the U.S. Here he has some advantages. He speaks American (he relinquished his U.S. citizenship in 2013, when he was elected to the Knesset). He is boyishly charming when he wants to be, unpretentious and pragmatic when necessary.
Bennett will deploy these skills to make friends in the anti-Bibi mainstream of the Democratic Party, even as he works to improve and expand the nuclear deal the U.S. is negotiating with Iran (stronger inspection, limits on ballistic missiles and restrictions on Iran's support for terrorist groups); and to nudge the administration's two-state diplomacy in the direction of the peace plan introduced by the Trump administration.
He will maintain ties with the Republican Party and evangelical Zionists while charming liberal Jewish leaders with his orthodox-lite tolerance, symbolized by a skull cap the size of a bottle cap. Beyond that, his main goal will be to stay on good terms with U.S. without getting sucked into its battles with China and Russia.
Bennett’s entire campaign was focused on avoiding a fifth election, so how he’ll prioritize policy areas is an open question. At home, Bennett’s success will depend largely on his ability to calm the rancorous political atmosphere brought by Netanyahu, keep his disparate fellow ministers on board, deliver post-Covid prosperity and push reforms of the legal system, social welfare and digital infrastructure (oddly enough, the “start-up nation” has one of the world’s slowest internet speeds).
Bennett proclaims himself a believer in Israel’s right to sovereignty in all of Jerusalem as well as the entirety of the West Bank, which the Israeli government refers to by its Biblical name, Judea and Samaria. But given his broad government and his narrow slice, it is a moot point.
Bennett may have a Biblical vision, but he has the foresight of a tech investor. As minister of education in a previous Netanyahu government, he substantially increased the number of high school students majoring in math and physics.
He is also a firm believer in the power of the marketplace. In a 2013 interview, he cited as a model the response of President George W. Bush to the 9/11 terrorist attacks on New York and Washington. “He told the public to go out and shop,” Bennett recalled. “Very patriotic.”
Of course, Bush also declared war on Iraq and Afghanistan. Bennett, who served as an officer in an elite combat unit, is no dove. If Israel is attacked again by Hamas, he will respond harshly. National security is the one issue for which he will have the broad support of his coalition as well as the Likud opposition.
Short of war, he will have a hard time getting much done in the two years of his term, or even keeping the coalition together that long. “Bennett is smart and determined,” says Roy Katz, host of the daily Free Market radio show, “but he will have comparatively little power. What he does have is the opportunity to change the national vibe. And that’s something Israel badly needs right now.”
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Zev Chafets is a journalist and author of 14 books. He was a senior aide to Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and the founding managing editor of the Jerusalem Report Magazine.
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.