(Bloomberg Opinion) -- President Donald Trump’s stock market bullying doesn’t appear to pack the punch it once did.
Harley-Davidson Inc. became the latest recipient of a Trump Twitter wedgie on Tuesday morning after the motorcycle maker said it was moving some jobs overseas in response to Trump’s escalating trade war.
Like companies before it, shares of Harley-Davidson fell and were off as much as 2 percent after the tweet. But Harley’s stock quickly rallied and was back to near even by the middle of the day. Investors have perhaps been learning that the president’s Twitter punches have had little follow-through. Consider Boeing Co.
That tweet knocked as much as 1 percent off Boeing’s shares, even though Air Force One is a minuscule part of the plane maker’s revenue. But back then, investors didn’t know how President-elect Trump would dole out punishment and reward from the Oval Office. A year later, Boeing’s shares had far outpaced the market, up 88 percent since the tweet.
The same was true of Trump’s General Motors smackdown on Twitter.
A year afterward, General Motors stock was up 27 percent, four percentage points more than the market during the period.
Or this one.
That sent Rexnord Corp.’s shares down 3.4 percent on the day of the tweet. But a year later, the stock of the industrial equipment maker was up nearly 21 percent, slightly better than the S&P 500 in the period.
Soon after Trump took office, T-3, a marketing firm, launched a trading bot that would quickly short any company that Trump tweeted about negatively. The bot racked up large gains in early 2017. But Ben Gaddis, president of T-3, said the strategy had been more of dud recently. “Trump’s tweets haven’t been as big a source of outperformance,” he said. “People are starting to shrug them off.”
The biggest reason is there has been little follow-through. Trump tweeted about Rexnord twice, threatening higher taxes specifically against it and other companies that move jobs overseas. But Rexnord closed its Indianapolis plant anyway and moved those jobs to Mexico. Rexnord has yet to suffer any presidential punishment. Instead, it has been rewarded, like the rest of corporate America. Rexnord’s effective tax rate plunged to 11.3 percent in the first quarter, down from 29 percent the year before.
Harley-Davidson, as my colleague Brooke Sutherland pointed out on Monday, is a pretty good example of the kind of company that will feel the brunt of the disruption in a trade war. Getting in front of that, by moving some jobs and production to countries where the goods will be sold, is a smart way for companies to react and probably a good move that will help its earnings and stock price. The punishment Trump proposed on Twitter doesn’t seem as if it would hurt the company anyway because Harley doesn’t plan to import motorcycles made outside of the country. The company’s decision most likely will not be “the beginning of the end,” as Trump tweeted. His exhortation the day before to exercise patience while he wins a trade war carries as much weight as his threats a day later. He probably can’t or won’t deliver on either, so companies need to make decisions in their best interests based on the situation in front of them.
The bigger takeaway for investors is that Trump’s pull on the market is not turning out to be as strong as some thought. Stocks soared after the election on what seemed at first like the Trump Bump, but that gain has since been credited to last year’s earnings rebound. Now, at least by one measure, the Trump stock premium has been mostly wrung out of the market. The average stock in the S&P 500 now has a price-to-earnings ratio, based on the next 12 months, of 16.9. On election day it was 16.8. It must be frustrating for a president who uses Twitter as a megaphone and stock prices as a barometer of success to realize that his barrages are rapidly becoming simple bluster.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Daniel Niemi at dniemi1@bloomberg.net
©2018 Bloomberg L.P.