Robinhood Adopts Meme Stocks Mantle and Their Violent Swings
(Bloomberg) -- Robinhood Markets Inc. has officially become a meme stock, and this week’s wild ride could be just the beginning if legions of amateur investors pull money from their old favorites to buy more shares while insiders are dumping them.
The trading app that helped fuel the memeification of the stock market soared and tumbled this week as individuals flipped shares. The stock rallied as much as 19% Friday and took center stage, ranking among the most actively traded companies valued at more than $500 million. Robinhood finished with a gain of 56.5% for the week.
Loyalists were building on the rally that added $30.2 billion of market value earlier in the week. Skeptics focused on Thursday’s 28% drop after insiders filed to sell a huge chunk of shares, including venture capitalists who took convertible stakes just six months ago at deep discounts in return for rescuing Robinhood from a margin call. The doubters also wondered aloud where individuals will get enough cash -- perhaps from other meme stocks -- to keep the rally alive.
“Investors need to recognize that this is going to trade like a crypto or other meme-related stocks in the short run and they could see significant positional changes,” said Eric Schiffer, chairman of Patriarch Organization, a Los Angeles-based private equity firm.
The insiders won’t be able to begin selling shares until they get clearance from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Robinhood said on Friday. That could take awhile; the company first must file its quarterly report with the SEC, something management doesn’t expect to do until Aug. 18.
This only delays rather than denies the day of reckoning. The insiders would still be positioned to take advantage of the recent surge while feeding shares in two parts to public investors at full market price. The impact on liquidity could be substantial: Only a fraction of Robinhood’s more than 700 million shares are currently available for trading.
Nora Chan, a spokeswoman for Menlo Park, California-based Robinhood, declined to comment beyond previous statements. “We’re not thinking about anything that happens in the market, especially in the short term,” Chief Executive Officer Vladimir Tenev said when the stock debuted. “The goal is to keep making great products, to keep improving the service and keep growing with customers.”
A three-day rally to start this week was triggered by news that Cathie Wood’s exchange-traded funds were snapping up shares and was refueled when options started trading Wednesday. Traders were quick to call out the impact, with the derivatives a key part of the tools individual investors use to power shares higher.
“You have good news, you have thin markets, you have these out-of-the-money strike prices being listed, and the trading volume looks like it overwhelmed option dealers,” said Christopher Vecchio, senior analyst at DailyFX.com. “It was the perfect recipe for a little bit of a gamma squeeze.”
Gamma squeezes happen when options dealers buy a rising stock to balance their exposure to contracts they have sold, pushing the shares even higher. The phenomenon was likely behind Wednesday morning’s 82% surge.
The stock’s meme status was cemented when it ranked as the most traded on Fidelity’s platform for most of the week, outpacing AMC Entertainment Holdings Inc. and Moderna Inc. Robinhood was also among the most popular stocks mentioned on StockTwits and Reddit, even as trading and prices for a basket of 37 meme stocks tracked by Bloomberg fizzled for a third week.
To be sure, that group is up over 60% this year with AMC rising more than 1,400% and GameStop Corp. up 700%. But with those shares cooling, retail investors might be tempted to swiftly rotate their paper gains into Robinhood. They’ve bought roughly $108 million of Robinhood since its debut, lagging the peak mania surrounding stocks like GameStop and AMC, data from Vanda Securities show.
“If retail investors start withdrawing money from tired meme stocks to buy HOOD, there is still room for the move to continue,” Vanda’s Ben Onatibia said.
The presence of amateur investors fueling rallies has made life difficult for fundamental analysts. Robinhood’s position at the center of it all drew Wolfe Research analyst Steven Chubak to start coverage with a peer-perform rating -- and advice to stay away.
“We cannot in good faith recommend investors get involved in HOOD on either the long or short side,” the analyst wrote on Aug. 5. There is “high ‘meme stock’ risk with outsized retail involvement,” which suggests Robinhood won’t trade on fundamentals.
Where meme traders strike next is anyone’s guess. The one thing many analysts agree on is that meme traders are playing a zero-sum game with limited cash -- they may need to sell companies they own to buy new ones.
“They can only spend so much money,” Vecchio said. “We will see quite a bit of interesting activity over the coming weeks.”
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.