Germany, AstraZeneca Deny Report of Vaccine’s Lower Efficacy in Elderly
(Bloomberg) -- The German health ministry and AstraZeneca Plc denied a newspaper report on the efficacy of the U.K. drugmaker’s Covid shot that further inflamed tensions over vaccine supplies between the company and the European Union.
Business publication Handelsblatt, citing unidentified sources in Germany’s ruling coalition, said late Monday that AstraZeneca’s vaccine is only effective for 8% of people older than 65. If true, that would have been a massive blow for immunization campaigns across the world, given that older people are most vulnerable to the pandemic.
Germany’s health ministry rejected the report, saying that the newspaper appears to have confused the purported efficacy figure with the 8% of test subjects in AstraZeneca’s trials who were between 56 and 69 years of age.
“This does not result in an efficacy of only 8% among seniors,” the ministry said in a statement.
Handelsblatt reaffirmed its story Tuesday evening. In an emailed statement, the newspaper said the German government still has doubts about efficacy among older people and it quoted an unnamed, high-ranking official from the health ministry as saying that confusion over the numbers was impossible.
An AstraZeneca spokesman called the Handelsblatt story “completely incorrect,” while a representative for the University of Oxford, which jointly developed the shot, said “there is no basis for the claims of very low efficacy.”
AstraZeneca shares traded 1% higher at 1 p.m. in London.
The vaccine showed an average of 70% efficacy in a phase 3 clinical trial, though two segments of the study showed different results. In one arm of the test, the shot was 90% effective while the other produced 62% effectiveness.
Participants in that study were mostly younger adults but earlier trials showed that the vaccine also produced a strong immune response in the elderly. The results of Oxford’s phase 2 study indicated that the vaccine is better tolerated in older people and produces a similar immune response in old and young adults.
The U.K. has approved the vaccine, while European Union regulators are reviewing it this week. Governments around the world are counting on the Astra shot to battle the coronavirus.
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.