Four Charts Show How World's Newest Oil Futures Fared This Week

(Bloomberg) -- The burden of a quarter century of expectations is weighing on China’s oil futures.

The yuan-denominated contract that was launched this week has lofty goals -- from providing a benchmark for buyers in the world’s biggest oil-consuming region to challenging the dominance of the dollar and encouraging the Chinese currency’s use in global trade.

The debut on Monday, which ended years of delays and setbacks since China’s first attempt to list the securities in 1993, was given a hand by some of oil’s biggest names including Glencore Plc and Trafigura Group. Yet data from the first few days of trading signal the futures have a ways to go for success.

A Costly Contract

Higher transaction fees and margin requirements are likely to limit foreign participation in the Chinese market, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. The transaction fee for Shanghai futures is about $3.20 per lot, compared with about $1.50 for U.S. oil contracts, the bank said.

Four Charts Show How World's Newest Oil Futures Fared This Week

The margin required to participate in China’s futures is 7 percent of the contract value, rising to 10 percent the month before delivery and 20 percent in the last three days before delivery. In the U.S., the margin is $2,100 a lot, or about 3.4 percent of the contract value, according to Goldman.

“Elevated transactions fees, margin requirements and position limits may ultimately dampen the size and price impact of INE speculative flows, with the exchange already publicly stating its desire to limit volatility and large price moves,” Goldman analysts including Damien Courvalin said in a March 28 note.

A Question of Price

Traders were watching for how the contract would be priced relative to other benchmarks, given its unique characteristics. While the futures were expected to be propped up by freight costs for transporting supply to China, the relatively lower quality of oil delivered into the contract signaled it would be dragged down versus European Brent and American West Texas Intermediate.

Four Charts Show How World's Newest Oil Futures Fared This Week

On Monday, traders brought down the price for September-delivery futures to levels close to Brent for that month. The Shanghai contract traded at a similar level, when adjusted for currency, for the rest of that session and Tuesday.

On Wednesday, though, the Chinese futures broke down sharply and found a new level, lower than Brent and higher than WTI. The fluctuations relative to the other benchmarks signal market participants are still assessing the appropriate value for the Shanghai contract.

Selective Liquidity

Ideally, the futures would be used to protect against price fluctuations down the line. However, trading in Shanghai has so far been concentrated in the front-month contract more than it is in other markets. The lack of liquidity for further out hurts the ability for industry participants -- drillers, refiners and fuel purchasers such as airlines -- to hedge future production or consumption.

Four Charts Show How World's Newest Oil Futures Fared This Week

“One of the concerns for China’s oil futures is the extremely high concentration on the nearby futures contracts,” said Jian Yang, J.P. Morgan endowed chair and research director at the J.P. Morgan Center for Commodities in the University of Colorado Denver. “It could be an indication of the lack of participation by hedgers.”

Fickle Speculators

On day two of trading in the Shanghai International Energy Exchange (INE), volumes on the bourse were more than four times as much as levels for Dubai Mercantile Exchange’s Oman crude contract. A closer look at open interest, however, points to a less positive picture for the Chinese exchange.

Four Charts Show How World's Newest Oil Futures Fared This Week

Open interest, a proxy for the amount of hedging activity, in the INE is significantly lower than that of DME. That “points to too much speculative trading on the China oil futures,” said Yang. Chinese exchanges are notoriously volatile; take for example its apple futures, where almost one million contracts -- the equivalent of $11 billion worth of the fruit -- traded on a single day in March.

That’s the kind of frenzy that Chinese regulators want to avoid because it undermines the reliability of the futures as a benchmark.

©2018 Bloomberg L.P.