What’s in the U.S.-China Phase One Deal and What’s Still Missing
(Bloomberg) -- Terms of Trade is a daily newsletter that untangles a world embroiled in trade wars. Sign up here.
The U.S. and China announced Friday that they reached a phase-one trade deal but provided little detail on what exactly will be part of the agreement.
U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer brought a print-out of the 86-page agreement to a briefing with reporters Friday afternoon as a “show-and-tell” to prove that it’s all done and written up. Lighthizer said it’s an important step forward for the two countries, while acknowledging that a lot of big issues are outstanding and need to be addressed in future negotiations.
Lighthizer appeared on the CBS News show “Face the Nation” on Sunday to discuss the deal, calling it “totally done” but headed for a transition period to undergo “some scrubs.”
Here’s what we do and don’t know:
As part of the deal, the U.S. will halve its 15% tariff on about $120 billion in Chinese goods. It will also suspend indefinitely planned duties that were set to take effect on Sunday that would have covered consumer favorites such as smart phones and laptops. That leaves roughly $250 billion taxed at 25% and $120 billion that will be subject to a 7.5% duty once the agreement takes effect. Any further tariff reductions by the U.S. will be linked to the conclusion of future phases, Lighthizer said.
China, on the other hand, didn’t agree to specific tariff reductions in the deal. Instead, the nation’s obligation is to make the purchases and to have an exclusion process for its tariffs. The country has in recent months lowered some retaliatory tariffs including some on cars imported from the U.S.
A USTR fact sheet refers to this part of the deal as the Expanding Trade chapter. According to the U.S., China has agreed to increase its total purchases of U.S. goods and services by at least $200 billion over the next two years. Also included is a commitment by China to increase its buying of U.S. agricultural products to $40 billion to 50 billion in each of the next two years. Lighthizer told reporters “these are numbers that are realistic and that we arrived at together.” The specific breakdown of targets for individual commodities will be classified and not disclosed to the public.
IP, Forced Tech Transfer
The deal will center around what a senior administration official called “state-of-the-art” IP commitments and a breakthrough on forced technology transfer. Those issues are also at the heart of an investigation that led President Donald Trump to raise tariffs on China in the first place.
Among the specific commitments USTR announced Friday: China has agreed to end its long-standing practice of forcing or pressuring foreign companies to transfer their technology to Chinese companies as a condition for obtaining market access, administrative approvals, or receiving advantages from the government. China also commits to provide transparency, fairness, and due process in administrative proceedings and to have technology transfer and licensing take place on market terms.
The agreement will include a dispute-resolution mechanism that will serve as the enforcement arm. That process is in line with how other U.S. trade agreements are enforced. Complaints of one party will be brought to a U.S.-China working group and if officials can’t resolve their dispute, a decision will be made at the ministerial level of what action to take. That action could include tariffs or other measures, Lighthizer said, though he sounded optimistic that he thinks China will keep their promises. On the CBS show, he said the provision lays out a 90-day enforcement period.
What Comes Next?
Lawyers are now reviewing the text so that it’s ready to be signed in the first week of January. It’s also being translated. Lighthizer and his counterpart Vice Premier Liu He will likely do the signing in Washington. Once it’s inked, the deal will take effect roughly 30 days later.
The president announced Friday that negotiations for the next phase would start immediately, though his trade chief said no date for future talks had been set. The first phase leaves contentious issues unresolved, including U.S. demands that China curb subsidies to state-owned firms. The U.S. says future talks will also focus on digital trade, data localization, cross-border data flows and cyber intrusions.
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.