Israeli Finance Minister Sees West Bank Economy Key to Peace
(Bloomberg) -- Israel’s finance minister is seeking to drum up American and European support for a plan to boost the Palestinian economy in the West Bank -- something he thinks will benefit Israel as well.
After more than three years of meetings with Palestinian officials, Moshe Kahlon is pushing a plan to build joint industrial zones, ease movement out of the West Bank and allow the Palestinian Authority to collect its own customs taxes. He will discuss the plan with U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and Jason Greenblatt, President Donald Trump’s Mideast peace envoy, later this month in Washington. The Trump team has pushed the notion that improving Palestinians’ standard of living will help create conditions for peace, and has pressed Israel for proposals.
“It isn’t always visible, but the economy makes an important contribution to what’s going on,” Kahlon said. “I’m a great believer in political process through economy.’’
Boosting the West Bank economy could shore up the Palestinian Authority, which has largely eschewed violence only to see Israel and other international actors propose aid for the Gaza Strip, where the ruling Hamas movement encourages anti-Israel attacks. Kahlon believes Israel also stands to gain from the West Bank plan if it lessens the impression of regional instability.
S&P Global Ratings earlier this month raised Israel’s foreign currency rating to AA-, citing strong growth prospects and improved fiscal policy, but Kahlon thinks the conflict with the Palestinians keeps Israel from being rated even higher.
“We’re raising money like countries with an AA+ or AA rating,’’ Kahlon said, pointing to a near-zero coupon on a 250-million euro private bond Israel placed last month with an Asian sovereign wealth fund. “It’s the security situation that pulls us down.’’
With Gaza boiling and no peace talks on the horizon, Palestinian officials declined to discuss their meetings with Kahlon. The Israeli prime minister’s office did not respond to requests for comment, and the White House declined to comment.
The Palestinian Authority has come out against an emerging cease-fire plan for Gaza that envisions international aid for the coastal strip, seeing it as a plot to circumvent its authority. Azmi Abdel Rahman, a spokesman for the Palestinian Authority Economy Ministry, similarly denounced Kahlon’s “unilateral” steps to help the West Bank. Any measures to aid the Palestinian economy must come in the framework of a comprehensive political deal negotiated with the Palestinian Authority, he said.
Improving the Palestinian economy does not come at the expense of their political aspirations, and the White House will take note of attempts by the Palestinian leadership to thwart economic benefits for their people, said a U.S. National Security Council official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter.
“There are a lot of prospects to find ways here to resolve some of these problems and give the people of Palestine, who have been used as agents by radical leaders over the years for their own political purposes, to give them and their families a chance for a decent life going forward,” U.S. National Security Adviser John Bolton said Wednesday at a news conference in Jerusalem.
Gross domestic product for West Bank Palestinians is about $4,000 per capita, about one-tenth of Israelis’. The economy has been handicapped by Israeli restrictions on movement and access, as well as Palestinian corruption and violence. Gaza’s economy is even worse off.
Kahlon’s proposal comes as Palestinians struggle to fill a void left by the U.S. withdrawal of $300 million in funding to UNRWA, the United Nations agency that serves Palestinian refugees. The Trump administration contends UNRWA perpetuates the Palestinian refugee problem rather than helping resolve it.
The U.S. visit will be Kahlon’s third time to discuss his proposals with the Trump administration. He also has met officials from France, Switzerland, Italy and Germany, and all “expressed a willingness to help,” he said.
Kahlon says plans are progressing for a joint industrial park to employ Arabs and Jews. He’s also trying to make it easier for Palestinian workers to cross into Israel from the West Bank.
Another proposal is for bonded warehouses where Palestinian officials could collect their own customs taxes, estimated at about 1 billion shekels ($273 million) per year. Palestinian imports arriving at Israel’s Ashdod port would go through a security screening before being packed onto trucks and sent to the West Bank.
“These are bigger steps than anything Israel has ever talked about, if it’s serious,” said veteran peace activist Gershon Baskin, founder of IPCRI - Israel-Palestine: Creative Regional Initiatives.
Economics of Peace
The notion that economics and peace go hand-in-hand is an old one: Shimon Peres championed the idea in the 1990s, arguing that Palestinians wouldn’t fight Israel if they had something to lose. That ideology was tested by the second intifada, a campaign of suicide bombings and armed attacks that erupted after years of rapid Palestinian growth. The Palestinian economy has yet to recover from the uprising, which ended when Israel built its West Bank separation barrier -- making it difficult for Palestinian attackers to reach their targets, but also for workers to reach their jobs.
The West Bank has remained largely quiet during recent Gaza border protests in which about 170 Palestinians have been killed and hundreds of rockets have been launched into Israel. As mediators craft a plan to ease the pressure on Gaza, Kahlon says it’s imperative that the economy of the West Bank -- which he calls by its biblical name, Judea and Samaria -- improve as well.
“My concern is that instead of rewarding the moderates and strengthening them, we’ll be doing the opposite, giving a prize to the problem child, a gift to the terrorists, while hurting those who behaved well,’’ he said. “This is very dangerous and could lead to an outburst of violence in Judea and Samaria. And, heaven forbid, if Judea and Samaria catch fire, it’s an entirely different thing.’’
©2018 Bloomberg L.P.