Taiwan's Overbanked Market Is Trying to Consolidate. Again
(Bloomberg) -- Regulators in Taiwan are taking another shot at consolidating a fractured financial system that’s scaring off foreign investors.
The island’s authorities last month made it easier for lenders to merge, part of a long-running campaign to whittle down an industry where assets are so thinly spread that banks struggle to compete with regional rivals. Government policy in the 1990s created a market where tiny entities carved out niches for themselves, making them fiercely independent.
Taiwan’s 37 banks have a total of $1.6 trillion in assets between them, roughly as much as Citigroup Inc. The crowd is a double-edged sword: Taiwan’s financial sector doesn’t have a single systemically important bank and the risk of a crisis is low, but margins have become so slim that global investors such as George Soros have exited over the years.
“Now it’s too difficult for the private sector to consolidate, especially as some small banks still operate quite well and big banks do not want to spend too much money for mergers,” said James Chen, a director at the Taiwan Mergers & Acquisitions and Private Equity Council. “The only thing the government can do is to force state-backed banks to merge, and tackle issues such as cutting staff and opposition from labor unions.”
Assets of Taiwan’s five largest lenders are only about 37 percent of the market’s total commercial banking assets, the third-lowest in the world after Nepal and Bangladesh, World Bank data show. In contrast, Singapore stands at 93 percent and China at 53 percent.
“Many Taiwanese banks have recognized that mergers are necessary to expand,” said Sherri Chuang, deputy director-general of the banking bureau of the Financial Supervisory Commission. “However, in Taiwanese culture, big shareholders tend not to sell their stakes as even small banks have good asset quality.”
Recognizing large stakeholders’ reluctance to sell, the regulator allowed smaller stakeholders to push for consolidation. In rules that took effect Nov. 30, the FSC said a bank or holding company that wants to buy another financial institution must have a minimum 10 percent existing stake in its target, lower than the 25 percent required earlier.
“Our regulators have been encouraging mergers,” Chao-Chin Tung, chairman of CTBC Bank Co., Taiwan’s biggest private lender, said in an interview at Bloomberg’s New Delhi office on Wednesday. “But I will do it only if it’s good for my company.”
CTBC Bank has limited opportunities to expand in Taiwan because it’s a small island with too many banks, Tung said. Taiwanese lenders earn average net interest margins of 1.36 percent, lower than the 1.43 percent among peers in Asia’s developed economies and 4.02 percent in the region’s emerging markets, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Yet, that may be enough for the players, says Michael On, president at Taipei-based Beyond Asset Management Co. He owns shares of Fubon Financial Holding Co. and Shinkong Insurance Co.
“The Taiwan market is small, and there are too many banks,” On said. “Still, everybody has small bites of rice to feed themselves.”
©2018 Bloomberg L.P.