Renault Rips Up Nissan Alliance Script for China Traction
Renault and Nissan had adopted a “leader-follower” strategy in May 2020.
(Bloomberg) -- Renault SA’s chief executive officer is fed up with the carmaker’s moribund business in China and willing to rip up the script the company and its alliance partner Nissan Motor Co. forged years ago to turn things around.
The French auto manufacturer and its Japanese counterpart adopted a “leader-follower” strategy in May 2020, where each company would occupy the driver’s seat in certain regions and the back seat in others. The goal was to revive cooperation and squeeze savings out of an alliance strained by the 2018 arrest of long-time leader Carlos Ghosn.
The plan assigned Renault, Nissan and Mitsubishi Motors Corp. core geographies where they would serve as a reference to the others to enhance competitiveness and share resources. But in setting out to turn things around in China, Renault CEO Luca de Meo has looked outside the alliance for help, pursuing a partnership with Geely Holding Group that includes selling hybrid cars in the world’s biggest auto market.
“Renault’s whole strategy in China was wrong,” de Meo told Bloomberg News on the sidelines of a media event last week. “It’s not Nissan’s fault. They may be leader in China, but they aren’t there to be charitable.”
The tie-up announced last year with Geely — which also controls Volvo Car AB and has shareholding ties with Daimler AG — spoke to the still-tenuous nature of relations between Renault and Nissan. While the automakers have scheduled a briefing for Jan. 27 to unveil new common projects, working together in China is low on their agenda.
Renault didn’t involve Nissan in its discussions with Geely that yielded a preliminary agreement in August, according to people familiar with the matter. While the two used to cooperate in areas including research and human resources, collaboration and communication has dwindled, said one of the people, who asked not to be identified because the deliberations aren’t public.
‘Spirit’ Continues
Representatives for Nissan didn’t respond to a request for comment. Makoto Uchida, Nissan’s CEO, told Bloomberg Television on Thursday that the “alliance will always have a strategic partnership together.”
“We have been working on multiple new technologies for electrification, including platforms, e-powertrains and batteries within the Alliance,” Uchida said. “We have already 21 years successfully achieving collaboration and synergies. This spirit and mindset will continue and this momentum has to be enhanced.”
Renault sold just 19,229 vehicles in China last year, dropping its market share in the country to 0.08%. Nissan’s China sales fell 5.2% to 1.38 million units, the automaker said Jan. 6.
“Nissan couldn’t rescue us,” de Meo said.
Geely and Renault announced Friday they’re moving forward with part of their framework agreement reached five months ago. The Renault-Samsung plant in Busan, South Korea, will make hybrid and combustion cars using a Geely architecture and powertrain technologies, with production forecast to begin in 2024. The pair haven’t yet finalized talks for Geely to help Renault sell hybrid vehicles in China.
Renault has a patchwork of partnerships in China that have been in a state of flux the last several years. It exited a venture with Dongfeng Motor Corp. in 2020 to focus on commercial vehicles and electric cars. In December of last year, it said its commercial-vehicle venture with Brilliance Auto Group Holdings Co. was unable to meet financial obligations and initiated a restructuring. It still has a production agreement with Nissan for the no-frills Dacia Spring EV, which is exported to Europe, and an EV venture with Jiangling Motors Corp.
“We’re trying to clean it up,” de Meo said of Renault’s business in China. The company likely will need a few years to pull off a project that’s innovative enough to stake out a share of the “pretty advanced” market, he said.
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.
With assistance from Bloomberg