Hong Kong Unrest Rocks Insurers’ Sales as China Buyers Balk
Hong Kong Unrest Rocks Insurance Industry as Chinese Buyers Balk
(Bloomberg) -- One of the biggest sources of demand for Hong Kong insurance products is drying up as the city’s summer of unrest deters Chinese buyers.
A group of about 80 agents working for one insurer saw their team’s sales to visitors from mainland China fall by almost 30% in August from the previous year, according to a senior member of the group. Sales for September are on track for another tumble, the person said. Two other agents in the city said their business had also fallen steeply after anti-government protests intensified. They all asked not to be named discussing private information.
Chinese customers have long flocked to Hong Kong for insurance sold by the likes of Prudential Plc and AIA Group Ltd., in part because the products offer an investment component and payouts in foreign currencies that are hard to come by on the mainland. But many prospective Chinese customers are now avoiding the former British colony after protesters disrupted transport services and engaged in violent clashes with police. That’s pummeling insurance sales because industry rules require policyholders to be physically present in the city before a contract can be finalized.
In one sign of how big the issue has become for insurers, Prudential this month arranged mobile processing centers in conference rooms at a hotel near Hong Kong’s airport, allowing visitors to sign their contracts without venturing into the city, according to a company memo seen by Bloomberg News. It’s unclear whether the move will alleviate customers’ concerns, given that the airport has also been rocked by protests in recent weeks.
Few expect the city’s turmoil to end any time soon, even after Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam last week gave into one of the protesters’ demands by scrapping the extradition bill that initially drew people onto the streets three months ago. The risk for Hong Kong’s insurance industry is that an enduring period of unrest undermines the city’s reputation as a safe and reliable provider of financial services.
“If this drags out more than a couple of quarters, it would do serious damage,” said Steven Lam, an analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence in Hong Kong.
A Prudential spokeswoman in Hong Kong confirmed the contents of the company’s memo, while declining to comment further. An AIA spokeswoman declined to comment.
The protests have thrown a wrench in what Hong Kong insurance agents -- some of whom quit careers in banking to join the lucrative industry in recent years -- had expected to be a strong 2019. New premiums from policies sold to mainland visitors increased 18% to HK$26.3 billion ($3.35 billion) in the first six months of the year from the same period of 2018, accounting for 26% of total new premiums from individuals, according to Hong Kong’s Insurance Authority.
If not for the unrest, sales would have been expected to remain robust as the Chinese yuan slumped, a move that typically increases demand for foreign-currency policies.
Instead, Chinese buyers have stayed at home as protesters blocked roads and clashed with police in districts such as Tsim Sha Tsui and Causeway Bay, where many insurers operate customer-service centers catering to tourists. The number of Chinese group tours to Hong Kong fell 90% in the first ten days of September versus the same period last year, following a 63% drop in August, according to data compiled by the Travel Industry Council of Hong Kong.
Prudential shares, which climbed 28% this year through early July in London, have since dropped about 16%. AIA has slumped about 10% from its July high in Hong Kong.
Assuming the current protests last six months, AIA’s value of new business may drop 5.6% in 2019, Michael Chang, an analyst at CGS-CIMB Securities Ltd., wrote in a note on Tuesday. “Our recent visit to mainland China suggests strong belief among people living in mainland China that it is currently unsafe to visit HK, and they are delaying or canceling travel plans.”
To contact Bloomberg News staff for this story: Alfred Liu in Hong Kong at aliu226@bloomberg.net;Evelyn Yu in Shanghai at yyu263@bloomberg.net;Stephen Tan in Hong Kong at ztan39@bloomberg.net
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Jun Luo at jluo6@bloomberg.net, Michael Patterson, Candice Zachariahs
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.
With assistance from Bloomberg