Giuliani Denies Defaming Dominion With Election-Fraud Claims
(Bloomberg) -- Donald Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani asked a judge to throw out a $1.3 billion defamation lawsuit by a voting machine company he accused of helping to steal the presidential election from his client, saying Dominion Voting Systems Inc. hasn’t shown it was injured by the claims.
Giuliani’s motion to dismiss Dominion’s Jan. 25 suit was filed Wednesday in federal court in Washington. The former New York mayor is accused of exploiting false election-fraud claims to hawk gold coins, cigars and supplements on a podcast.
The case is one of several that Dominion filed over baseless claims made in the aftermath of the election that it conspired to switch votes from Trump to Joe Biden. The company has also sued Fox News and former Trump campaign attorney Sidney Powell, as well as MyPillow Inc. Chief Executive Officer Mike Lindell, all of whom have publicly accused Dominion of helping to steal the election from Trump.
In his Wednesday filing, Giuliani portrayed himself as a victim, claiming that Dominion made 50 “false and defamatory statements” about him in its complaint. He said the lawsuit improperly sought “exorbitant” damages without actually identifying any financial harm it suffered as a result of the lawyer’s claims about Dominion.
The filing didn’t attempt to back up any of Giuliani’s wild claims about Dominion, but it suggested he may do so later if the case continues. Dominion has said it wants a full trial to expose what it says is total lack of evidence that he had any reason to believe what he said about the company.
“Should this matter reach legal or factual adjudication on the merits, Giuliani will provide a vigorous and complete response,” his lawyer, Joseph D. Sibley, said in the 10-page filing.
Dominion attorney Megan Meier, of Clare Locke LLP, said in an emailed statement that Giuliani’s attempt to dismiss the suit contradicts his previous pledges that he would back up his voting-fraud claims.
“Giuliani said he wanted to present the ‘evidence’ for his defamatory statements about Dominion, but now he’s trying to avoid a trial and still offering no evidence at all,” Meier said. “Dominion will continue to pursue accountability for Giuliani in a court of law.”
Claims of widespread voting fraud advanced by Trump, Giuliani, Powell and others were rejected by dozens of judges across the country. Trump’s attorney general, William Barr, also said there was no evidence to support such claims.
The suit against Giuliani was filed a few weeks after the conspiracy claims helped inspire the deadly Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. Trump and Giuliani both spoke at a rally that preceded the riot.
Fox News has defended its coverage and moved to dismiss a similar suit filed by a Dominion competitor. Powell is seeking to dismiss the suit against her, saying “no reasonable person” would believe her claims were “statements of fact.” Lindell has also denied Dominion’s claims.
Dominion, based in Denver, has raised the possibility of suing Trump himself. In December, it sent a letter to the White House asking that documents be preserved for possible litigation. It sent similar letters to Fox News and competing conservative media outlets like One America News and Newsmax as well as individual commentators.
The case is Dominion v. Giuliani, 21-cv-213, U.S. District Court, District of Columbia (Washington).
©2021 Bloomberg L.P.