Fiat Seeks Dismissal of GM Suit Over Alleged Union Bribes
(Bloomberg) -- Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV asked a federal court to dismiss a racketeering lawsuit General Motors Co. hit the Italian-American automaker with two months ago, saying the U.S. company’s theory “defies economic logic.”
GM alleged in November that Fiat Chrysler inflicted billions of dollars in damages by bribing United Auto Workers leaders for competitive advantages that the union denied to GM. The biggest U.S. carmaker also accused Sergio Marchionne, the late chief executive officer of Fiat Chrysler, of conspiring with the UAW in his years-long attempt to merge the two companies.
In its filing to have the suit dismissed, Fiat Chrysler rejects the racketeering allegations and argues GM can’t prove it was the primary party injured by a corruption scandal that has engulfed Fiat Chrysler and the UAW.
Fiat Chrysler says concessions it made to the UAW in 2015, allegedly to hurt GM, harmed it as well. Fiat Chrysler also argues that the racketeering complaint can only be adjudicated by the National Labor Relations Board and its injury claims were filed too late.
“It is a predictable tactic taken by the defendants,” GM said in a statement. “We are confident in the legal and factual underpinnings of our case.”
Former officials at the carmaker and union took funds from a training organization they jointly ran to exchange gifts -- including credit cards, golf trips, designer clothing, furniture and jewelry -- as part of a plan by the automaker to keep UAW leaders “fat, dumb, and happy,” according to federal prosecutors.
Fiat Chrysler denied that it either directed or approved any of the alleged payments, although it acknowledged that some employees improperly used funds belonging to the training organization.
“It makes no difference whether the alleged prohibited payments were made directly by FCA to UAW, as GM contends, or were instead facilitated by former FCA employees acting in violation of clear company policies, as the facts will show, because GM’s claims fail either way,” Fiat Chrysler said in its filing.
Fiat Chrysler, which agreed to merge with France’s PSA Group in December, reiterated its belief that GM’s suit amounted to an attempt to undermine its combination with the maker of Peugeot and Citroen cars.
The case is General Motors LLC v. FCA US LLC, 19-cv-13429, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan.
©2020 Bloomberg L.P.