Democrats’ Health-Care Feud Eclipses Message That Won in 2018
Democrats’ Health-Care Feud Eclipses Message That Won in 2018
(Bloomberg) -- In the four evenings of Democratic presidential debates since June, one phrase appeared for the first time on Wednesday: “pre-existing conditions.”
New Jersey Senator Cory Booker uttered it in his remarks on health care, chiding fellow Democrats for their infighting as Republicans wage a legal battle to undo the Affordable Care Act, which prohibits insurers from charging people more for being sick.
“The person who is enjoying this debate the most tonight is Donald Trump,” he said. “There is a court case working through the system that’s going to gut the Affordable Care Act and actually gut protections on pre-existing conditions,” Booker said, citing litigation in which the Trump administration and Republican-controlled states seek to strike down Obamacare.
Over two nights this week, the 20 candidates spent at least an hour fiercely arguing over health-care plans, most of which are significantly more expansive than what the party enacted a decade ago in the Affordable Care Act. It’s a sign of how important the issue will be in the bid to unseat Trump, and how the party’s position has shifted leftward.
In November, Democrats won control of the House on the strength of their message to protect people with pre-existing conditions. That provision, a fundamental change to America’s private insurance market, is central to the ACA, the party’s most significant domestic policy achievement in a generation.
Booker’s attempt to unify his fractious colleagues against their common opponent stood out, because most of the discussion of health care, which kicked off the debate as it did on Tuesday, put the party’s divisions into sharp focus.
Biden v. Harris
Senator Kamala Harris of California and former Vice President Joe Biden tried to discredit each other’s proposals. Biden says he wants to build on the Affordable Care Act while expanding access to health insurance through a public insurance option.
Harris, in a plan unveiled this week, likewise favors a public option but wants to sever the link between employment and health insurance, allowing people instead to buy into public or private versions of Medicare, the federal health-care program for seniors.
Harris took Biden to task over a plan that fails to insure everyone, saying his plan would leave 10 million people without insurance.
“For a Democrat to be running for president in America with a plan that does not cover everyone, I think is without excuse,” she said.
Biden accused Harris of having had “several plans so far” and called her proposal a budget-buster that would kick people off health plans they like.
“You can’t beat President Trump with double-talk on this plan,” he said.
Other candidates split along similar lines, with Colorado Senator Michael Bennet saying Harris’s proposal “bans employer-based insurance and taxes the middle class to the tune of $30 trillion.”
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio argued for a more sweeping approach, like the Medicare for All policies embraced by Senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren.
“I don’t understand why Democrats on this stage are fear-mongering about universal health care,” he said. “Why are we not going to be the party that does something bold, that says we don’t need to depend on private insurance?”
How Bold?
The question any candidate will eventually have to answer is how bold a plan they believe voters in a general election want.
In 2018, Democrats running for Congress attacked Republicans for trying to repeal the ACA and then, when that failed, asking courts to find it unconstitutional. Scrapping the law would mean about 20 million people lose health insurance.
About two-thirds of the public, including half of Republicans, say preserving protections for people with pre-existing conditions is important, according to polls by the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonprofit health research group.
More than a quarter of adults under 65 have pre-existing conditions, Kaiser estimates.
But that message has been mostly absent from the primary debates, where health-care talk highlights the divisions between the party’s progressive left wing and its more moderate center.
Warren and Sanders weren’t on stage Wednesday, but their presence was looming. They’re both leading candidates and have deeply embraced Medicare for All plans that replace private insurance with a government plan.
Whichever candidate emerges from the primary will have to take their health plans not just to fervent Democrats, but to a general electorate as well.
To contact the reporter on this story: John Tozzi in New York at jtozzi2@bloomberg.net
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Drew Armstrong at darmstrong17@bloomberg.net, Mark Schoifet, Bill Faries
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.
