Coal Demise Forces $1 Billion Writedown for Swedish Utility
Vattenfall AB took a massive hit on the value of a new German coal plant in yet another sign of how the fossil fuel is struggling in Europe.
The Swedish utility wrote down the value of the Moorburg facility in Hamburg by 9.1 billion kronor ($1 billion), according to its first-half earnings statement on Tuesday. The plant opened in 2015 and by then Vattenfall had already taken impairment losses of 4 billion kronor for the project.
The writedown is another example of how renewable energy and the global pandemic is reshaping energy economics. Demand for power dropped more than 20% in some European countries during the lockdown, leading coal’s share in generation to plummet as green sources like solar and wind have priority on the grid.
“For understandable reasons, fossil-fired power generation is especially exposed in today’s challenging market,” Vattenfall’s Chief Executive Officer Magnus Hall said in the statement. “A natural consequence of this is that the value of fossil-fired plants is decreasing.”
The plant has drawn controversy since it started. Environmentalists in both Germany and Sweden slammed the state-owned utility for opening a coal-fired plant at a time when utilities, cities and governments should do all they can to reduce carbon emissions. Vattenfall said earlier this year it was considering options for Moorburg and was willing to discuss its future with the city.
Germany has plans to phase out most hard-coal plants in Europe’s biggest power market by 2026 and several other European nations are following suit. The U.K. went for more than two months without any coal in its power system this spring.
The cost of carbon emission permits have also hit a 14-year high, reducing profitability at coal plants even further. At the same time, natural gas is trading at near-record lows.
“Moorburg is getting whacked by a corona-linked drop in power demand that’s also hurting exports on which coal power has relied for several years,” said Bruno Burger, a professor at the Fraunhofer ISE institute in Freiburg, Germany. “Add to that cheap gas, expensive pollution certificates and growing renewables and hard coal is getting booted out of the market.”
Moorburg generated 7.6 terawatt-hours of power in 2017. So far this year, it has generated a mere 1.1 terawatt-hours, Burger said.
In September, Germany will run its first auction of capacity to close hard-coal plants. Hard-coal power generation dropped by a third last year to just 9% of the nation’s power mix. A lobby group for the nation’s coal importers said last week that it expects steam-coal shipments to fall by a similar amount this year to a record.
Vattenfall was also forced to write down the value of its Swedish wind assets by 1.5 billion kronor. Power prices in the Nordic market slumped to records this spring after the biggest surplus of water for hydro power in decades.
“Falling electricity prices are having a substantial and negative impact on Vattenfall,” said Hall, which also said he will depart the utility in January next year at the latest.
©2020 Bloomberg L.P.