A Hellish Week for Cathay Buffeted Between China and Hong Kong
Cathay Had a Week From Hell Caught Between China and Hong Kong
(Bloomberg) -- For more than half a century, Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd. has been Hong Kong’s gateway to the world, its British heritage and Asian high-altitude luxury fusing the city’s colonial past with its Chinese location. But it’s that unique cultural blend that has ensnared the carrier in an increasingly out-of-control political uprising sweeping through the streets.
After months of anti-Beijing demonstrations in the city, Cathay is emerging as the corporate fall guy as it struggles to navigate a path between the demands of the mainland and employees sympathetic to the uprising. In a dramatic escalation, Chief Executive Officer Rupert Hogg resigned on Friday, capping a tumultuous week in which the carrier was rebuked by China’s regulator, boycotted by state-owned companies and excoriated by nation’s biggest bank.
China’s actions give the 72-year-old carrier a taste of a less autonomous future awaiting the airline, and other companies with a Hong Kong presence are also being dragged into the political quagmire.
Fashion houses Versace, Coach, and Givenchy were forced to apologize for selling T-shirts that didn’t properly designate Hong Kong as part of China. HSBC Holdings Plc said it became the subject of “groundless” rumors on the Web that linked recent executive changes to shareholder pressure. And PricewaterhouseCoopers LLC stood accused on Chinese social-media platforms of not condemning the demonstrations forcefully enough after a company-linked online post (which the firm said was a fraud) appeared to support the uprising.
China’s Warning
“Cathay is only the start,” said Shukor Yusof, founder of aviation consultancy Endau Analytics in Malaysia. “China is sending a message to other corporations in Hong Kong that the same thing can happen to them.”
The orders by China’s aviation regulator last Friday laid bare the airline’s vulnerabilities, and its conundrum: Staff who support illegal protests are banned from Cathay services to the mainland. And all Cathay crew need special approval to enter Chinese airspace, a crackdown that also affects many flights heading to the U.S. and Europe. Though Cathay doesn’t disclose a breakdown of its mainland China business, flights originating from there and Hong Kong account for about half of the firm’s revenue.
Add the 272 scrubbed flights and 55,000 stranded passengers after protesters occupied Hong Kong’s airport and this week has turned into one of the worst in the carrier’s history. And even before Hogg’s abrupt departure, Cathay spent the last few days trying to make amends.
Merlin Swire, chairman of the airline’s biggest shareholder, went to Beijing to meet with aviation officials on Monday, and Cathay fired two pilots who’d been suspended in relation to the protests. A Cathay representative declined to comment on the company’s relationship with China, referring to an Aug. 12 message to employees where the carrier said it is obliged to comply with regulations from the nation’s aviation authorities. Cathay also said it won’t tolerate illegal activities.
Hogg took over in May, 2017, having served previously as Cathay’s chief operating officer. He joined Hong Kong property and trading conglomerate Swire Group, Cathay’s biggest shareholder, in 1986 and was appointed Cathay’s director of cargo in 2008.
On Tuesday, Cathay stock tumbled to its lowest close in more than 10 years. It’s rebounded somewhat since as Cathay worked to undo the damage of its link to the protests, but the stock’s 6.8% drop this year still puts it among the 10 worst-performing carriers on the Bloomberg World Airlines Index.
Union Strike
The unrest in Hong Kong initially targeted a controversial proposed extradition bill. As the dominant local airline, Cathay was affected mostly because the protests put off tourists. But its troubles deepened after Cathay pilot and flight-crew unions took part in a general strike on Aug. 5.
Days later, the Civil Aviation Administration of China stepped in. Cathay’s actions, or lack thereof “have led to a severe threat to aviation safety, created negative social impact and increased the risk of flying from Hong Kong to the mainland,” the regulator said.
On top of subjecting employees flying to the mainland to checks, CAAC ordered Cathay to submit a plan to increase safety and tighten security by Aug. 15. All the information handed over by Cathay so far has met requirements, according to the regulator on Thursday.
Almost simultaneously, Chinese state-run companies began blacklisting Cathay. China Huarong International Holdings Ltd., a unit of the country’s largest bad-debt manager, told workers to choose another airline for business and even personal trips, people familiar with the matter said. Finance-to-brewing conglomerate China Resources National Corp. was said to give similar directions to its staff. China Citic Bank International Ltd., a Hong Kong-based unit of the nation’s largest state-run conglomerate, sent a message to its workers on Wednesday, saying it was to ensure travel safety.
Then, on Tuesday, a brutally bearish research report landed on Cathay from state-run Industrial & Commercial Bank of China Ltd. analyst Zhao Dongchen predicted Cathay stock would slump by about one third to HK$6 in 12 months, a level it last reached in 2001. Zhao criticized Cathay’s leaders for “poor crisis management” that would cause “irreversible damage” to the airline’s brand. No other analyst comes close to Zhao’s depth of pessimism on Cathay, data compiled by Bloomberg show.
The political upheaval comes at an already difficult time for Cathay. The airline’s leading position in Hong Kong, Asia’s busiest hub for international traffic, has long been under threat from regional rivals. A new airport in Beijing is due to open next month, potentially siphoning off more business. Throw in sluggish global economic growth, the U.S.-China trade war and a fragile business emerging from a turnaround, and the prospects are increasingly gloomy.
But Cathay’s problems aren’t necessarily China’s concern. The company seems an obvious target for Chinese authorities as the protest movement shows no sign of stopping, said Paul Yong, an analyst at DBS Bank in Singapore.
“It’s really an issue of symbolism,” said Yong. “It’s long been an icon of Hong Kong. It meant it attracted more attention from the Chinese authorities.”
China and Britain have waged a war of words over the unrest in Hong Kong. The U.K. government in June threatened “serious consequences” if China failed to honor an agreement that guarantees freedoms in Hong Kong. China, in turn, accused Britain of meddling.
For many, Cathay is an emblem of the years Hong Kong was governed by Britain, until 1997. The airline is almost half-owned by the two-century-old conglomerate headed by the U.K.’s Swire family, where Hogg and Chairman John Slosar are long-time Swire lieutenants. The carrier’s second-largest shareholder? State-run Air China Ltd.
In some respects, Cathay appears to have given in. Though Slosar said this month the company “wouldn’t dream of telling” staff what to think about issues such as Hong Kong’s protest movement, the company changed its tune after drawing scrutiny from China’s aviation regulator.
“We must and will comply,” Hogg said.
--With assistance from Bruce Einhorn and Wendy Hu.
To contact the reporters on this story: Kyunghee Park in Singapore at kpark3@bloomberg.net;Angus Whitley in Sydney at awhitley1@bloomberg.net
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Young-Sam Cho at ycho2@bloomberg.net, Ville Heiskanen, Benedikt Kammel
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.