Skyscraper City Becomes Citadel of Putin's State Capitalism
(Bloomberg) -- Russia built it, but they didn’t come.
Two decades in the making, Moscow City is finally filling up with tenants, just not necessarily the kind Russia had in mind when it conceived the glass-and-steel district as an international financial hub.
With the economy besieged by sanctions and some of its biggest companies becoming pariahs in western capital markets, Russia is cramming the high-rises with ministries and the biggest state firms. Now, the central bank is also discussing a possible relocation of some employees, according to two people familiar with the matter.
“What’s happening in City reflects the trend in the economy,” said Valery Vaisberg, head of research at IK Region, an investment company in Moscow that manages 346 billion rubles ($5.9 billion) in assets. “Many of the towers ended up with state banks because other tenants can’t afford such prices.”
Already home to two of the top state lenders, the sprawling development in western Moscow will soon be host to oil pipeline monopoly Transneft PJSC, with the ministries of economy, communications and industry aiming to relocate there next year. Sberbank PJSC, the biggest bank, is in a tower less than a mile away. Industry and Trade Minister Denis Manturov said on Monday that his ministry wants to move as soon possible but probably won’t do it before May 2018.
The Bank of Russia may soon be VTB Group’s neighbor in one of Europe’s tallest skyscrapers, although no decision has yet been made, according to the people, who asked not to be named because the matter isn’t public. The central bank isn’t planning to abandon its headquarters in a 19th-century mansion in central Moscow, they said. Moscow’s government has also bought a half of another tower.
The central bank’s press service didn’t confirm or deny plans for moving some personnel to the financial district, saying in response to a request for comment that it’s looking for ways to house its Moscow staff of more than 10,000 more efficiently.
Economy Minister Maxim Oreshkin has said his ministry will relocate along with some of the agencies it oversees, including the statistics service. The move will bring together officials now split between three main buildings in the Russian capital, with the current setup resulting in so much lost time that it’s equivalent to one ministry department being constantly on the road, Oreshkin said in an online interview last week on the Gazeta.ru news site.
It’s a reversal from Moscow City’s early days, when the likes of International Business Machines Corp. and KPMG LLP snapped up the premises, with the share of foreign businesses peaking at 80 percent in 2006. More than a decade later, Russian companies account for 71 percent of the total space, according to Colliers International. The government and state-run firms make up a third.
The takeover began after the global credit squeeze almost a decade ago, when the failure of developers gave their creditors among state banks ownership of properties in the district. When Russia plunged into recession in 2015, and demand for new offices collapsed, lenders opted to use the space for their own needs, according to Alexander Bazhenov, an office-market analyst at Jones Lang LaSalle Inc. in Moscow. In 2015, vacancies in Moscow City reached 40 percent, he said.
“Against that backdrop, financial institutions began to consider putting their own offices in buildings they wound up owning,” he said.
The transformation mirrors a shift in the Russian economy that accelerated in recent years but started years ago under President Vladimir Putin. Instead of offering Russia’s answer to London’s Canary Wharf, the new skyscraper city is becoming a monument to top-down state capitalism. In the decade after 2005, the state’s share in the economy doubled to 70 percent of gross domestic product, according to Russia’s anti-monopoly service.
The state takeover only intensified since a standoff with the West escalated in 2014 and the crash in oil prices gutted the economy. As talk of reform remained muted, almost two years of recession left Russia with little to fall back on. That’s allowed the government to muscle in.
For Moscow City, the arrival of state tenants was a matter of survival after occupancy rates tanked at the height of the economic crisis. Now, Colliers says properties are in demand even before the end of construction, and vacancies are at less than a fifth, down from almost half just a few years ago.
Rental prices in Moscow City are among the highest in the Russian capital, with Class A office space costing as much as 44,000 rubles per square meter, according to Bazhenov at Jones Lang LaSalle.
The district, which combines offices with commercial and residential space, hasn’t entirely become a colony of the state. Russia’s largest miner MMC Norilsk Nickel PJSC and pipeline builder Stroytransgaz are moving in. Western companies are also present, albeit in small numbers.
“The state’s growing presence in the economy is playing out in City,” said Natalia Orlova, chief economist at Alfa-Bank in Moscow. The effect “isn’t only direct but is also implemented via companies in segments where 10 years ago there was no plan to raise the state’s role.”
(A previous version of this story corrected a company name in the penultimate paragraph)
©2017 Bloomberg L.P.