Bad-Debt Pioneer Has Sobering Advice for India Bargain Hunters
Be prepared to stay for the long haul and deal with multiple setbacks.
(Bloomberg) -- As local and foreign investors line up to pick bargains out of India’s $207 billion bad-loan debacle, one of the country’s most seasoned managers of distressed assets has some sobering advice: Be prepared to stay for the long haul and deal with multiple setbacks.
“Managing many of these complex assets on a day-to-day basis is going to be very tough, as this is not a market where you can just jump in and out and make money,” said Vinayak Bahuguna, chief executive officer of Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd., which has been buying bad loans for about 15 years.
India is embarking on its most far-reaching effort to break up distressed corporate borrowers and resolve soured debts, and global money-management titans from J.C. Flowers & Co. to Apollo Global Management LLC are eyeing investments. The cleanup will not only test India’s legendary bureaucracy and its newly-restructured courts system; it must also overcome some business owners’ determination to frustrate any attempts to auction off their assets on the cheap.
Few executives know more about the potential pitfalls than Bahuguna, who has had a 30-year career in banking, including a stint managing distressed loans in India and Africa at Standard Chartered Plc. Arcil has bought bad loans totaling 815 billion rupees ($12.6 billion) since it was set up in 2002 as India’s first asset-reconstruction company, backed by ICICI Bank Ltd. and other large lenders.
Indian insolvencies take longer to resolve than in any other major economy, and only in Brazil do creditors typically recover less. Overall, India is No. 103 in the World Bank’s ranking of how nations handle insolvencies, just behind Nicaragua.
All this adds up to the need for an experienced local partner to help navigate the Indian system, Bahuguna said. “If you are looking at more than one opportunity here, then a local foothold is important,” he added.
Over the next year, the assets and debt of about 50 of India’s biggest defaulters may be sold off by court-appointed professionals, a process in which banks are expected to take deep haircuts on their loans. The companies’ borrowings total an estimated 3 trillion rupees, close to one-third of total recognized bad loans in India’s banking system.
The bankruptcy courts are due to rule on the first twelve of those companies -- known locally as the “dirty dozen” -- in the first quarter of 2018. After being overhauled by the government last year, the courts are supposed to speed up the lengthy insolvency process.
Billionaire Uday Kotak, India’s richest banker, in an interview this month called the investment opportunity stemming from the process a “once in a lifetime event,” and said that sovereign wealth funds and global pension funds have expressed interest. Canadian pension fund Caisse de depot et placement du Quebec and Brookfield Asset Management Inc. have publicly said they may invest in Indian stressed assets.
For all the excitement, one of the first cases the courts handled was hardly encouraging. Following a verdict in August, creditors managed to recover just 6 percent of Synergies-Dooray Automotive Ltd.’s total defaulted debt of 9 billion rupees, because there wasn’t adequate collateral.
Establishing the title to Indian property often requires manual searches because records in many cities have yet to be uploaded into digital form, Bahuguna said. A local partner is also useful for foreign firms attempting to deal with other complexities such as wrangling with minor co-creditors, enforcing guarantees and managing any political interference from regional authorities where the defaulting company operates, he added.
“This maze has to be navigated guardedly,” Bahuguna said. “While the system is already in place, it is yet to be tested by large cases.”
For all the various obstacles, Bahuguna still sees the potential for lucrative investments. Arcil has more than 10 billion rupees available to buy soured debt, and has tie-ups with some large overseas funds willing to co-invest significantly higher amounts, he said, declining to name them.
“As long as smart investments are made, there are good returns that can be made,” Bahuguna said.
--With assistance from Adrian Leung
To contact the reporter on this story: Anto Antony in Mumbai at aantony1@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Marcus Wright at mwright115@bloomberg.net, Philip Lagerkranser
©2017 Bloomberg L.P.