Modi’s Fifty Million Homes Moonshot Faces Ground Reality

(Bloomberg) -- India’s ambitious ‘Housing for All’ plan is bumping up against some harsh realities.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi set a target in 2015-16 of building 50 million homes in less than a decade, or about seven million a year. The nation has since added only 214,560 under the scheme, underscoring the challenge in achieving that target.

“It was a moon shot,” said Rajesh Krishnan, chief executive officer at Brick Eagle, a Mumbai-based private equity fund that provides project financing to affordable housing developers.

Modi’s housing program is a necessity in a nation where about 65 million people, or the population of the U.K., live in make-shift structures in cities such as Mumbai, which is home to Asia’s second-largest slum. An added benefit is that it promises to stoke employment and unleash investments, estimated at as much as $1.3 trillion over seven years, as the government plans a re-election bid in 2019.

Yet, as the numbers attest, there’s no shortage of roadblocks. Demand is concentrated among the nation’s poor, India doesn’t have sufficient developers able to mass-produce apartments and myriad clearances add to project costs already elevated by high land prices.

Over 96 percent of the urban housing shortage is due to households earning less than $9,310 per year, according to Shirish Sankhe, a Mumbai-based senior partner at McKinsey & Co. That means home prices need to be kept at less than a million rupees ($15,532), which can be a challenge given the construction and land acquisition costs, he said.

Further driving up costs are state, central, environmental and civil aviation-related clearances that delay construction. India ranked 185 out of 190 countries in dealing with construction approvals, according to a World Bank report showing that Asia’s third-largest economy comes in at 130 for its overall ease of doing business.

Cumbersome Process

“Anywhere else in the world you can get approvals in 30 days time, here it takes a year, sometimes two years,” said Neel Raheja, group president of Mumbai-based K. Raheja Corp. “You also have legal challenges on land title, which are even more cumbersome when you tackle the affordable housing opportunity.”

To draw builders in, the government has offered those constructing affordable homes so-called infrastructure status, making them eligible for various incentives. Interest-rate waivers were extended to households with annual incomes of up to 1.8 million rupees, while laws to tackle building delays and protect home buyers came into effect on May 1.

Leading developers including Mahindra Lifespace Developers Ltd., an arm of the Mahindra Group, Tata Housing Development Company Ltd. and Raheja Developers have responded, though they are yet to have a serious impact. 

Affordable housing projects in cities across India increased in the first half of the year, driven by the National Capital Region, Kolkata, Pune and Ahmedabad, where 80 percent of launches were in this segment, a Knight Frank report showed this month. Most efforts are focused on the middle-income group, where apartments cost 2 million to 3.5 million rupees,  McKinsey’s Sankhe said.

Tata Value Homes, the affordable housing arm of the $100 billion Tata Group, has delivered more than 8,000 apartments priced from 1.4 million rupees to 7 million rupees, a company spokesman said by email. Mahindra Lifespaces ventured into this space in 2014 and has delivered 500 homes so far in the 1.8 million rupees to 2.3 million rupees range, according to Sriram Mahadevan, business head at the company’s affordable housing unit.

In addition to the rural housing count under Modi’s scheme, the government has also been working to complete about 3.6 million homes from a previous program, Indira Awaas Yojana, according to an April statement from the ministry of rural development. Including the backlog shows 3.2 million rural homes were constructed in financial year 2017, a 78 percent increase in activity compared with a year earlier, Ravi Sodah and Harsh Jhanwar, Mumbai-based analysts at Elara Capital, wrote in a May report.

Land Prices

One way of encouraging developers to focus on cheaper units would be for the government to lower land prices by releasing some of the property parcels owned by agencies such as the Indian Railways, said Anuj Puri, chairman of ANAROCK Property Consultant. Land currently accounts for as much as 50 percent of the cost of a project within city limits, he said.

“The lack of affordable and adequately-sized land parcels in core urban areas has driven the development of affordable housing projects to urban peripheries.” said Mahindra Lifespaces’ Mahadevan. “It is important to develop projects in strategic locations that are fast-growing, have basic social infrastructure and offer ease of connectivity.”

--With assistance from Anto Antony

To contact the reporter on this story: Dhwani Pandya in Mumbai at dpandya11@bloomberg.net.

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Marcus Wright at mwright115@bloomberg.net, Candice Zachariahs, Sree Vidya Bhaktavatsalam