Brokerages See Near-Term Concerns For Tata Motors After Q3 Earnings Miss

Few Downgrades For Tata Motors Despite Weak Earnings

A fully operational Land Rover Series One automobile sits waiting for body and interior work at Land Rover’s Classic Workshop in Solihull, U.K (Photographer: Matthew Lloyd/Bloomberg)

Shares of Tata Motors declined as much as 8.6 percent on Wednesday, making it a fifth straight day of losses for the homegrown auto major after its third quarter earnings missed street estimates by a wide margin.

Investors and traders took short positions in the stock after it reported a year-on-year decline of 96 percent in its profit for the quarter-ended December.

While most analysts admitted at being negatively surprised by the company’s performance, their reaction has been limited to a downward revision in price target while keeping rating on the stock mostly unchanged.

CLSA On Tata Motors

  • Downgraded to ‘Sell’ from ‘Buy’
  • Price target cut to Rs 405 a share from Rs 650 a share
  • Expect margins to contract sharply for Jaguar Land Rover and India
  • Expect hedging losses to continue at high levels
  • See rising incentives due to demand pressures
  • Cuts financial year 2018-19 earnings per share estimates by 25 to 31 percent

Citi On Tata Motors

  • Retain ‘Buy’ rating, price target of Rs 660 a share
  • Near-term concerns remain but margins guidance is strong in the medium-term
  • Jaguar Land Rover’s model cycle seen to improve
  • Healthy volumes growth, margins should aid free cash flows

Jefferies On Tata Motors

  • Retains ‘Buy’ rating, price target of Rs 606 a share
  • Jaguar Land Rover’s volume outlook remain strong but margins to remain in focus
  • Average selling price benefitted considerably on account of GBP depreciation
  • Higher than forecasted cost items, weaker mix led to margin contraction
  • Management commentary on margins suggests an improvement but mildly so
Get live Stock market updates, Business news, Today’s latest news, Trending stories, and Videos on NDTV Profit.
WRITTEN BY
Agam Vakil
With a master's degree in business, Agam has over 15 years’ experience in r... more
GET REGULAR UPDATES